As research grows, editorial and peer review systems face increasing pressure to keep up.
While balancing multiple responsibilities, peer reviewers invest significant time reviewing manuscripts and academic publications. Yet, traditional review methods struggle to keep pace with the growing volume.
AI tools for peer review can save reviewers’ time by automating tasks like manuscript screening, gap identification, and spotting ethical issues. As a result, they speed up the overall review process and help with better decision-making.
Having said that, let’s discuss how artificial intelligence can revolutionize how you approach the peer review process.
Top 8 AI Peer Review Tools for Accurate Feedback
- ⏰60-Second Summary
- The Role of AI in the Peer Review Process
- What Should You Look for in AI Peer Review Tools?
- The 8 Best AI Peer Review Tools
- 1. ClickUp (Best for document and review process management)
- 2. Grammarly (Best for grammar refinement and writing clarity)
- 3. Perplexity AI (Best for finding reliable data sources)
- 4. Scite (Best for enhancing research credibility)
- 5. CodeGuru Reviewer (Best for code reviews)
- 6. Scholarcy (Best for reviewing academic research and textbooks)
- 7. Peerceptiv (Best for collaborative peer assessments and team evaluations)
- 8. Trinka AI (Best for technical and academic writing correction)
- Other Notable AI Tools for Peer Review
- Enhance Peer Review Speed and Accuracy With ClickUp
⏰60-Second Summary
Here are the eight best AI peer review tools:
- ClickUp: Best for document and review process management
- Grammarly: Best for grammar refinement and writing clarity
- Perplexity AI: Best for finding reliable data sources
- Scite: Best for enhancing research credibility
- CodeGuru Reviewer: Best for code reviews
- Scholarcy: Best for reviewing academic research and textbooks
- Peerceptiv: Best for collaborative peer assessments and team evaluations
- Trinka AI: Best for technical and academic writing correction
Without further ado, let’s get started!
Summarize this article for me pleaseThe Role of AI in the Peer Review Process
AI is transforming peer review by boosting efficiency, speed, and transparency. It tackles key challenges like reviewer availability, bias, and the rising manuscript volume.
Key benefits of AI in peer review include:
- Efficiency and speed: Processes extensive submissions rapidly and performs initial screenings for relevance and compliance, reducing turnaround times
- Bias reduction: Provides objective assessments based on predefined criteria, mitigating unconscious biases related to gender, affiliation, or origin for fairer reviews
- Misconduct detection: Identifies plagiarism, data fabrication, and image manipulation through pattern recognition and database comparisons, safeguarding against academic publishing fraud
- Reviewer selection: Recommends suitable reviewers based on expertise and publication history, streamlining the selection process
- Consistency and thoroughness: Generates structured peer review reports and applies standardized criteria uniformly, minimizing subjectivity.
- Quality assessment: Analyzes manuscript content, compares it to existing literature, and flags potential flaws in research methodology or data analysis to enhance manuscript quality
Summarize this article for me pleaseWhat Should You Look for in AI Peer Review Tools?
Choosing the right AI peer review tool can significantly boost productivity while preserving the quality of your review process. With these features in mind, you’ll find a tool that enhances document review and supports human peer reviewers in making accurate, informed decisions.
Here’s what to look for:
- Accuracy of feedback: Choose tools that reliably mimic human expertise by precisely identifying gaps, weaknesses, and improvement areas, ensuring scientific rigor
- Customizable review parameters: Opt for tools that allow flexible review criteria tailored to journal or institutional requirements
- Platform integration: Ensure seamless integration with your document management workflow and publication systems to minimize platform-switching time
- Quality training data: Prioritize tools built on high-quality, comprehensive datasets for nuanced and contextually accurate insights
- Reviewer fatigue reduction: Automate initial reviews to ease reviewer workload, allowing humans to focus on final evaluations
- Ethical issue detection: Select tools capable of spotting ethical concerns like conflicts of interest, research biases, or data manipulation that may escape manual reviews
These tools use AI for productivity, making the peer review process more efficient and helping ensure that high-quality control standards are maintained throughout.
Summarize this article for me pleaseThe 8 Best AI Peer Review Tools
Here are the eight best AI peer review tools you can use to make peer reviewing more efficient:
1. ClickUp (Best for document and review process management)
ClickUp is the everything app for work that simplifies document review with templates, automation, and AI.
With real-time collaboration and document automation features, ClickUp eliminates the need to sift through endless files or spend hours manually reviewing documents.
ClickUp Docs acts as a centralized hub, keeping all documents organized and accessible for easy sharing. You can collaborate in real time, add comments, edit, and track changes effortlessly.
Document version control keeps everything updated and transparent, especially for legal teams or projects with multiple stakeholders.
You can further accelerate your review process via ClickUp Tasks. Use Custom Statuses like in-progress, completed, and rejected, along with ClickUp Task Checklists.
These features help track progress, ensure every task is covered, and improve team collaboration. Clear roles, timelines, and responsibilities keep everyone accountable, whether you’re reviewing contracts or finalizing policy updates.
📮ClickUp Insight: 92% of workers use inconsistent methods to track action items, which results in missed decisions and delayed execution. Whether sending out follow-up questions and notes or using spreadsheets, the process is often scattered and inefficient. ClickUp’s Task Management Solution ensures seamless conversion of conversations into tasks—so your team can act fast and stay aligned.
ClickUp Brain adds another layer of efficiency. It generates concise summaries, highlights key points, and creates tasks automatically. Grammar fixes and sentence improvements make your documents clearer and easier to understand.
You can also ask specific questions about tasks or projects to receive instant answers and detailed feedback.
ClickUp’s Automations help optimize your workflows further. You can create custom rules to assign tasks, update statuses, and automate follow-ups. For example, a task is created automatically when a document is uploaded, and reviewers receive reminders.
ClickUp best features
- Correct spelling and grammar issues with the built-in spelling and grammar checker
- Speed up tasks with content writing templates and peer review templates tailored for various needs
- Transcribe videos and translate notes into multiple languages effortlessly
- Connect over 1,000+ apps, including Slack, Google Drive, and Zoom, to simplify workflows without switching screens
- Edit and write from anywhere using the mobile app
ClickUp limitations
- First-time users may feel overwhelmed by its extensive features and customizations
ClickUp pricing
- Free Forever
- Unlimited: $7/month per user
- Business: $12/month per user
- Enterprise: Contact for pricing
- ClickUp Brain: Add to any paid plan for $7/month per user
ClickUp ratings & reviews
- G2: 4.7/5 (10,000+ reviews)
- Capterra: 4.6/5 (4,300+ reviews)
What real-life users are saying about ClickUp
Feedback from Cristina Willson, Director of Content at Graphite:
2. Grammarly (Best for grammar refinement and writing clarity)
Designed for everyone, from educators to marketing professionals, Grammarly transforms your content into polished, professional work. With integrations like Google Docs, Grammarly is accessible right where you need it.
You can use it as a web app, browser extension, or mobile tool to refine and improve your writing anytime. Even better, access Grammarly’s full suite of features within your ClickUp workspace.
Grammarly best features
- Rewrite sentences and paragraphs with its AI assistant for more concise and impactful communication
- Fix typos, grammar mistakes, and punctuation errors for polished communication
- Adjust tone and mood to communicate ideas more effectively
- Create a consistent brand voice using shared writing guidelines
Grammarly limitations
- Requires manual review of grammar corrections
- May misinterpret user intent, resulting in occasional inaccurate suggestions
Grammarly pricing
- Free
- Premium plan: $30/ per month
- Business plan: $25/user per month
- Enterprise: Custom pricing
Grammarly ratings & reviews
- G2: 4.7/5 (10,500+ reviews)
- Capterra: 4.7/5 (7,000+ reviews)
What real-life users are saying about Grammarly
From a G2 review:
👀Did You Know? Nearly 80% of manuscripts are rejected during the peer review process.
3. Perplexity AI (Best for finding reliable data sources)
Finding the right answers can sometimes feel overwhelming, but that’s where Perplexity AI shines. It combines the precision of a research tool with the ease of a conversational assistant, delivering fact-based insights backed by credible sources.
Unlike other AI content creation tools, which are great for creative writing, Perplexity AI focuses on providing accurate, research-driven responses.
Perplexity best features
- Get responses with cited sources to verify the accuracy
- Pull verified data from trusted references for tackling complex or niche questions
- Use a simple interface to find answers faster
- Choose between multiple LLMs like DeepSeek R1, OpenAI, Claude, Sonar, etc. in the paid plans
Perplexity limitations
- Generates fewer creative responses compared to similar AI tools
- Chances of missing newer data if not indexed in its source references
Perplexity pricing
- Standard: Free
- Professional: $20/user per month
- Enterprise Pro: $40/user per month
Perplexity ratings & reviews
- G2: 4.7/5 (40+ reviews)
- Capterra: Not enough reviews
What real-life users are saying about Perplexity
What a G2 reviewer wrote:
🧠Fun Fact: Albert Einstein’s first article review was for a paper titled On the Theory of the Brownian Movement, written by Polish physicist Marian Smoluchowski. Smoluchowski sent the paper to Einstein for feedback, and Einstein was struck by both its clarity and innovative ideas. In his review, he described Smoluchowski’s work as “one of the most important contributions to the theory of Brownian motion” he had encountered.
4. Scite (Best for enhancing research credibility)
Revolutionizing how we engage with scientific literature, Scite AI’s innovative features bring a fresh perspective to academic research.
At its heart is Smart Citations—a tool that goes beyond citation counts to explain their context. It clarifies whether a citation supports, contrasts, or simply mentions a paper, helping users gauge a study’s relevance and impact quickly.
Scite best features
- Use the AI Assistant to get precise, citation-backed answers to research inquiries
- Trace research lineage with citation chaining for better insights into how ideas evolve
- Access advanced literature search tools with robust filtering for faster, relevant results
Scite limitations
- The AI Assistant relies on existing literature, which may miss novel or interdisciplinary approaches that aren’t documented yet
Scite pricing
- Personal: $7.99/month per user
- Organization: Custom pricing
Scite ratings & reviews
- G2: Not enough reviews
- Capterra: Not enough reviews
Also Read: How to Use AI to Review Documents
5. CodeGuru Reviewer (Best for code reviews)
Code reviews often feel like a challenge in development, but Amazon’s CodeGuru Reviewer simplifies the process. This platform allows you to easily log into the AWS Management Console, commit your code, and create a pull request.
Once that’s done, the service analyzes the code for critical issues. It then generates a detailed report showing what was flagged, why it was flagged, and how to fix it.
CodeGuru Reviewer best features
- Bring security checks directly into CI/CD pipelines to follow security best practices
- Speed up code evaluations and locate elusive bugs with accuracy
- Perform full repository scans periodically to maintain consistent code quality
CodeGuru Reviewer limitations
- Support is limited to a few languages, including Java, Python, and JavaScript
CodeGuru Reviewer pricing
- Custom pricing
CodeGuru Reviewer ratings & reviews
- G2: Not enough reviews
- Capterra: Not enough reviews
🧠Fun Fact: The earliest recorded use of peer review in scientific publishing dates back to 1752, when the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society adopted the system.
6. Scholarcy (Best for reviewing academic research and textbooks)
Ever wish you could break down dense research papers or textbooks into digestible insights? Scholarcy makes it possible.
It distills dense content into crisp, bite-sized summaries, capturing key points without the slog of endless paragraphs. Now, with its latest YouTube video summarization feature, you can extract essential insights without watching hours of content.
Scholarcy best features
- Adjust summaries to match your reading preferences using the ‘Enhance’ option
- Save summaries as flashcards and store them in your library for future reference
- Add browser extensions to summarize online articles directly without switching tabs
Scholarcy limitations
- Processes content slower than some other summarization tools
Scholarcy pricing
- Free plan
- Monthly Plan: $4.99/month
Scholarcy ratings & reviews
- G2: Not enough reviews
- Capterra: Not enough reviews
What real-life users are saying about Scholarcy
From a G2 review:
7. Peerceptiv (Best for collaborative peer assessments and team evaluations)
Peerceptiv has been redefining how complex tasks are assessed for over two decades. From peer evaluations to team member reviews, it provides an all-encompassing solution that transforms learning into a collaborative process.
Its seamless integration with various learning management systems makes it versatile for institutions aiming to scale their programs while keeping costs manageable.
Peerceptiv best features
- Set flexible grading weights for submissions, peer reviews, and team evaluations
- Use custom rubrics tailored to specific assignments
- Get flexible deadlines to accommodate diverse schedules
Peerceptiv limitations
- Lacks an integrated communication channel, unlike similar tools
Peerceptiv pricing
- Custom pricing
Peerceptiv ratings & reviews
- G2: No ratings available
- Capterra: No ratings available
Also Read: How to Use AI for Documentation
8. Trinka AI (Best for technical and academic writing correction)
Writers and publishers worldwide rely on Trinka AI for polished, error-free content. From correcting spelling mistakes to paraphrasing and checking for plagiarism, it delivers editing precision, earning it a spot among the top AI peer review tools.
Trinka caters to diverse writing styles, whether academic, technical, or general. This versatility makes it a go-to tool for review processes, offering advanced support while seamlessly handling process documentation needs.
Trinka AI best features
- Proofread documents in MS Word and edit LaTeX files without affecting TeX code
- Customize editing with personalized style guides
- Integrate with platforms like Microsoft Word, Google Docs, and PowerPoint
Trinka AI limitations
- Requires time to configure personalized goals
Trinka AI pricing
- Basic
- Premium: $20/month
- Premium Plus: $10.41/month (billed annually)
- Sensitive Data: $41.67/month
- Enterprise: Custom pricing
Trinka AI ratings & reviews
- G2: Not enough reviews
- Capterra: Not enough reviews
What real-life users are saying about Trinka AI
What a G2 reviewer wrote:
Summarize this article for me pleaseOther Notable AI Tools for Peer Review
Here are a few other tools that didn’t make it to the top eight in our list but are worthy of a try:
- Enago Read: This is a user-friendly tool with AI that helps simplify manuscript screening and review. If you mainly need references from open-access sources, try it out
- Consensus AI: A powerful AI-based search engine, this tool has been designed especially for academic research. It helps in locating and summarizing extracts from peer-reviewed articles
- Penelope AI: This AI tool automates manuscript checks for everything from metadata to ethical approval, speeding up the journey to publication
Summarize this article for me pleaseEnhance Peer Review Speed and Accuracy With ClickUp
Peer review is the backbone of research quality—but without AI, the process can be slow, error-prone, and resource-intensive. Manual reviews by human reviewers often lead to missed details, inconsistent feedback, and delays that hinder progress.
ClickUp’s AI-powered features transform the peer review workflow. Leverage natural language processing to automatically categorize submissions, generate summaries, and suggest improvements—all while enabling seamless collaboration across teams.
Built-in automation tools handle repetitive tasks and track progress, giving your team more time to focus on delivering high-quality, insightful reviews.
Simplify peer review, boost productivity, and maintain scientific excellence. Try ClickUp for free!
Everything you need to stay organized and get work done.
